9.8 C
Sunday, October 13, 2019
Connecting Our Communities

Woolwich still at odds with owner of wrecking yard over methane

Headache over site of former municipal dump expands to include issues about trailway access, water line on property


Meet the candidates

By Veronica Reiner & Aneta RebiszewskiFive candidates are vying for your vote in...

Kitchener-Conestoga too close to call

With less than five percentage points separating the Conservatives and Liberals in the riding, Kitchener-Conestoga has become too close...

Organizers aim to put environment at the forefront of election

The federal election underway, environmental groups are looking to make issues such as climate change a central part...

Putting the green in the initiative

The woodlot in Elmira's South Parkwood subdivision attracted 35 volunteers who planted 150 trees Oct. 5....
Steve Kannon
Steve Kannonhttps://www.observerxtra.com
A community newspaper journalist for more than two decades, Steve Kannon is the editor of the Observer.

A makeshift pathway connecting the Kissing Bridge Trail and Bolender Park in Elmira is being removed after the township and property owner failed to come to an agreement.

The two are also at odds over a municipal waterline that runs through the 86 Auto and Metal Recyclers property on Arthur Street – an investigation revealed there was never an easement reached allowing access to the site.

The pair of trespassing issues come in the wake of uncertainties about methane from an old municipal dump under part of the site and the park itself. The extent of the methane problem is still under review, as are methods for dealing with it.

Woolwich is waiting on input from the Ministry of the Environment at this point, a process that has dragged on.

The delays are part of the frustration for property owner Frank Rattasid, who has come across roadblocks in his attempts to operate a metal recycling operation at 39 Arthur St. N. Faced with what he calls a lack of cooperation from Woolwich officials, the township’s incursions on his land – the pathway and the water line – are all the more troublesome, he says.

Clouding matters are ongoing efforts to test for methane on the site, an issue that Rattasid notes he was assured was no longer a problem. Woolwich had in fact removed a pump-driven venting system that had been installed years ago, before a problem was discovered anew.

“I have a problem that I didn’t think I had. This is not my problem,” he said Tuesday.

Frank Rattasid
Frank Rattasid hopes 86 Auto and Metal Recyclers and U-Pull-It Elmira will be well used by the community for recycling scrap metal and pulling parts for their vehicles. [Whitney Neilson / The Observer]
Facing inconveniences and possible expenses, he said he’s like to see some compensation, either monetary or in the form of cooperation with his plans to expand the scope of the operation.

Currently, he operates the auto wrecking business on five of the 12 acres he owns. The other seven are zoned as open space, so can’t be used as part of the business. Among the many proposals he’s brought to the township is a plan to use five of the seven acres, turning over the remaining two acres to the township as a buffer zone between his site and the neighbours. That would also allow for a pathway and access for the water line.

He’s also floated other offers, including selling the seven acres to the township or perhaps even the entire site.

“I gave them a number. I thought it was a reasonable number, not much more than I spent for it,” said Rattasid, adding he sees future development potential for the site.

Woolwich chief administrative officer David Brenneman acknowledges that Rattasid has presented a number of scenarios, but said the details are a property issue that could only be discussed by councillors in a closed meeting.

“He certainly has made some proposals,” Brenneman said. “Mr. Rattasid is certainly always exploring options.”

On the issue of expanded uses at the site, he maintains the longstanding opinion that Rattasid will have to make a formal application for a zoning change or perhaps a minor variance before that can be considered.

“If he wants to diversify the use on the property or expand … he needs to make an application.”

He acknowledged that the methane is an issue. The township is looking to work with Rattasid to do more testing and to install some kind of methane-disbursement system down the road if necessary.

For his part, Rattasid maintains that a township proposal to use a trench system – as opposed to the former below-ground pumping option – could prove disruptive to his operation.

Brenneman counters that the township will look at ways to minimize the impact.

Work on the methane situation is in limbo, however, as they wait for the MOE to respond.

In the meantime, the township is looking at options for moving both the pathway to Bolender Park and the water line.

With the water line, engineering staff is looking at coming up with a “cost-effective way” to relocate the service.

Township rec. staff will be removing the makeshift bridges on township property and posting signs about trespassing, said Brenneman. The department is also looking at alternatives for connecting the trail to the park.

“Mr. Rattasid notified us he wanted to do some cleaning of the back part of his property. He had mentioned that he was going to take that out,” he said of this week’s removal of the pathway on private property.

“I want the trespassing to stop because there’s a liability aspect,” said Rattasid, noting there’s been no progress on his attempts to get the property in township hands, for instance.


  1. This is an excellent article by the Observer and in my opinion is much more nuetral and balanced than earlier ones. This article indicates that the Township provided inaccurate information to Mr. Rattasid regarding the presence of methane. Having read all ten reports by the Township’s consultants (CRA now GHD) it was obvious to me that methane still existed in the subsurface of this site. The evidence otherwise was extraordinarily thin and only the most naive or hopefull would think it even remotely adequate. The township are in the wrong in all matters pertaining to the Bolender Park Landfill and their recalcitrance on the methane issues could cost property damage or much worse.

  2. Kudos Woolwich Observer. This is an excellent article . Woolwich township are reaping what they have sown. They have been uncooperative and hostile towards this business and the Rattasid’s from day one. Woolwich are completely in the wrong not just on the trespassing issues (waterline & pathway) but especially regarding the methane problems. The Township have ignored common sense and their own consultants in not properly addressing the dangerous levels of methane around the entire Bolender Park Landfill, not just at the Rattasid’s auto recycling yard.

Comments are closed.

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to The Observer's online community. Pseudonyms are not permitted.By submitting a comment, you accept that The Observer has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner The Observer chooses. Please note that The Observer does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our submission guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.


Program encourages Girls to give it a Go

Whether you’re a girl in need of a new friend or just someone to hear you out, Big Brothers Big Sisters of Waterloo Region (BBBSWR) is offering a seven-week GoGirls mentoring program at the...

In Print. Online. In Pictures. In Depth.

You obviously love community journalism. Thanks for visiting today. If you have a great local story, let us know.

Young Breslau martial artists continue to excel, collect hardware

It’s been another successful run for a pair of Breslau siblings, who crushed two martial arts tournaments in the past month.

Shantz family doesn’t have to look far to find new owner for historic schoolhouse building

With fall’s arrival, change is in the air, but that’s not reserved just for the weather. A St. Jacobs historical landmark is being...

Former Wolfpack soccer player earning accolades as part of St. Thomas University team

Former Woolwich Wolfpack soccer player Brett Springer was recently recognized for his outstanding performance and sportsmanship as the athlete of the week for the...

Music that’s designed to give you a lift

Audiences can expect an authentic atmosphere, soul-stirring ballads, and plenty of interaction with the cast in Drayton Entertainment’s latest offering.Now...

A mixed-bag for Jacks as streak ends

The Wellesley Applejacks suffered their first regulation loss of the season last Friday, bouncing back to post a tie and a win as...
- Advertisement -