20.5 C
Thursday, May 28, 2020
Their View / Opinion

So what’s wrong with a $4 turkey?

Afriend of mine – let’s call her Tara, because that’s her name – visited relatives in Michigan over the Christmas holidays, and noticed the price sticker for that evening’s turkey dinner proudly displayed on the refrigerator door.

It read $4.

Not $4 a lb. – $4 for the whole turkey.

Her hosts were ecstatic. They thought they’d snagged the bargain of the season and were eager to celebrate it.

But the price stuck in Tara’s craw.

“I knew it was somehow wrong to be giddy over a $4 turkey,” she said later, “but I didn’t exactly know why.”

It turns out she was struggling with the lure of cheap food. We’re all drawn into supermarkets by what are called loss leaders – that is, products the retailer purposefully sells at a loss just to get shoppers into the store. Once they’re in, the thinking goes, they’ll buy enough other regularly priced items for the store to still make a profit.

Loss leaders are part of our overall shopping culture. Consumers get a deal, and maybe stores benefit at the till, where they’re clamouring for sales. Food retailing is highly competitive in Canada; we continually rank among the top five countries in the world that devote the least of our take-home pay to food.

But even though Canadians (and Americans) dedicate comparatively little to our food budget, rising food prices are still consumers’ biggest concern. So from purely a price perspective, Tara’s relatives can hardly be blamed for rejoicing about their $4 Christmas miracle.  

Here, though, is the difference.

When loss leaders are dry goods, such as paper towels or toilet paper, few people along the supply chain will experience hardship or in fact hardly even notice.

However, it’s a different story when the loss leader is something that can be connected to your neighbour’s farm, like meat or vegetables … because somewhere along the line, there’s a chance that farmers are getting shafted.

Staple foods sold as loss leaders create an expectation that they should always be bargain priced. And unless farmers have a bottomless treasury behind them – like some U.S. farmers have lately, thanks to their president throwing billions of dollars of subsidies at them – that’s just not possible.

Farming is a business, and businesses have to be profitable.

But the U.S. Christmas turkey scenario underlines how Canadian farmers are falling behind and are calling on the federal government for help.

Feed is a livestock farmer’s biggest expense. U.S. farmers who buy feed for their animals have been getting a bargain since the Trump subsidies began. They offset the true cost of feed production and allow U.S. farmers to sell it for less. Feed producers don’t need to make as much money from their crop when they’re getting big subsidy payments from Trump.

As a result, the cost of producing animals, like turkeys, goes down in the U.S.

Canadian grain producers don’t have the same kind of support as their American counterparts. But because the U.S. is such a huge grain exporter, its price is the price that everyone else is forced to charge.

In Canada, the price and production of turkey is controlled. That means farmers here have more latitude to implement animal welfare and food safety measures. It doesn’t mean turkeys in the U.S. are treated inhumanely or that their meat is not high quality. But the edge goes to Canada.

So what’s wrong with a $4 turkey?

There’s Tara’s next dinnertime discussion.

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to The Observer's online community. Pseudonyms are not permitted. By submitting a comment, you accept that The Observer has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner The Observer chooses. Please note that The Observer does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our submission guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

We're looking for opinions that count.

Yours. Join in the conversation, provide another viewpoint, change minds with your perspective.


Now we’re lining up to get overcharged for booze

The sustained lineups in front of LCBO stores tell us booze is deemed essential through the coronavirus pandemic, the employees there frontline...

A quick recovery from economic downturn appears unlikely

Health concerns still dominates the story of the novel coronavirus, but the economic impacts of the resultant lockdown are more than a...

Basic income: a done deal?

The First World War speeded up the emancipation of women; the Second World War led to the creation of welfare states in...

The fantasy life of Jordan Goudreau

It’s hard being born Canadian if your ambition is to be a real-life version of movie tough guy Jean-Claude Van Damme (Blood...

Frontline food workers to Ontario: We’re here for you

We’re pretty attached to our neighbourhood butcher. He’s always been renowned for quality, let alone service and friendliness. And...

Tree planting is cool. So why not crop planting

Arguments over whether international workers or homegrown Canadians should provide the labour to grow our crops and raise our livestock fizzle when...

Dealing with the implications of a near-tragedy

The other day, a good friend of mine called to tell me about an unfortunate thing that happened to him. He was...

Conestoga heroes

I once read that Leonardo da Vinci slept five hours a night – which I find hard to believe, since they did...

Love is a drug, with real medicinal benefits

Q.  Have you heard talk about a “love medicine”?  Is it a new wonder drug? A.  It’s certainly wonderful...

We have many phobias, and the words to describe our fears

Q.  2020 marks the 200th anniversary of the birth of Florence Nightingale, founder of the nursing profession and undoubtedly the most famous...
- Advertisement -