-1.3 C
Friday, November 15, 2019
Connecting Our Communities

U.S. posturing over Iran proves no lessons learned in the Gulf


Restored Victorian home in Elmira the subject of TV competition

Along with the influx of visitors that comes with the holiday season, Elmira will see one new...

End of an era for MP

Two weeks having passed since the federal election, Harold Albrecht has had time to reflect on his...

Candidates make pitch to voters in Woolwich

Largely sticking to their respective party lines, the five candidates running in the Kitchener-Conestoga riding made their one all-candidates...

Meet the candidates

By Veronica Reiner & Aneta Rebiszewski Five candidates are vying for your vote in...


clear sky
-1.3 ° C
2 °
-4 °
74 %
1 %
4 °
-0 °
1 °
3 °
4 °

urrent U.S. saber-rattling over Iran evokes a very strong sense of déjà vu: a weak but tough-talking president in need of a distraction, a military buildup in the Persian Gulf and officials travelling abroad to find allies in a bid to censure a Middle Eastern country.

There are more than a few shades of the 2003 invasion of Iraq in current hyperbole about Iran.

That a similar scenario is playing out despite the fiasco that was Iraq speaks volumes about the Trump administration. The occupation of Iraq cost hundreds of thousands of lives and fleeced U.S. taxpayers out of more than $2 trillion despite a failing effort that was eventually shown to be unjustified and built on a foundation of lies.

One would like to think Americans won’t be taken in – fool me once … – but things don’t always go that way. Allied countries, however, are likely to be much more skeptical this time around – the coalition of the willing ain’t what it used to be.

Iran isn’t Iraq. It’s much bigger and controls a strategic waterway through which as much as a third of the world’s oil flows. It’s in many ways worse than Iraq in terms of its policies and affronts to human standards, but that alone isn’t enough to justify, say, a massive bombing campaign (the U.S. won’t be eager to put boots on the ground).

From crackdowns and killing of protesters, to the seizure of hostages and the murder of foreign nationals, Iran’s militant rulers have won themselves few friends in the world. That’s made it easy to international support for sanctions, especially those related to controlling Iran’s bid for nuclear weapons, but there’s no appetite for the death and destruction that would come with the war. Even for hawks, the interests of the oil industry may trump the desire to impose U.S. will on yet another reluctant state.

Therein lies the issue that arises in any discussion about the region: oil. We might not care for the people we get it from, but we want it nonetheless.

So far, concerns about Iran’s nuclear ambitions and very real support for Islamic militants play second fiddle to the flow of oil, particularly to China and Russia, both of which have veto power at the UN Security Council.

The U.S., too, has much at stake in the region. While chastising Tehran, their hold on the moral high ground is precarious.

Having invaded Iraq under dubious pretexts, the U.S. position was steadily undermined by revelations that the reasons for war were unfounded.

Iran may indeed be a major threat to the region – there are plenty of experts who make a case for that stance. But the Americans, having been exposed as liars in Iraq, cannot now count on support for action against Iran, if only increased sanctions led by the United Nations.

Ironically, the case against Iran is much stronger than it was in Iraq. Iran’s previous nuclear posturing and fundamentalist bent are far larger threats. Still, that country is only of interest because of its natural gas and oil reserves, and for its strategic location. If Iraq is any model, those factors will play the largest role in whether the war expands to Iran.

There are many real reasons to censure Iran, but none of them have to do with protecting human rights and ridding the world of an evil dictator. Those making noises about Iran are guilty to some degree of supporting dozens of vile regimes led by dictators who terrorized their own people. The United States, which supported Saddam Hussein for years, has a long record of backing, arming and aiding those who practiced atrocities. The list of repressive, often genocidal regimes is long (see Vietnam, Cambodia, East Timor, Nicaragua, Honduras, El Salvador, Chile, Kosovo, Rwanda,etc.); examples of righteous indignation leading to action and justice are much harder to find.

Right or wrong, the current war posturing must be judged against this larger picture. No one can rightly claim moral superiority

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to The Observer's online community. Pseudonyms are not permitted. By submitting a comment, you accept that The Observer has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner The Observer chooses. Please note that The Observer does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our submission guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.


New watering system is powered by the sun

Many hands may make light work, but automating the process really lessens the load. That’s especially helpful when the work involves relying on volunteers to provide the manual labour.

In Print. Online. In Pictures. In Depth.

You obviously love community journalism. Thanks for visiting today. If you have a great local story, let us know.

EDSS looks to make use of new push for skilled-trades training

With measures taken on the provincial level to encourage high school students to enter the skilled trades, EDSS is in the process...

Junior girls’ capture EDSS’ first WCSSAA basketball title

In a season that already saw the team rack up win after win, the EDSS junior girls’ basketball team reached new heights...

Virgil Wins the Lottery … but, then again, maybe not

It’s easy to day dream about striking it rich quick by winning the lottery, and all the possibilities that come along with...

Pair of convincing wins sees Jacks improve record

A pair of wins last weekend saw the Wellesley Applejacks jump a notch in the PJHL standings to claim second place in...

Sugar Kings turn the screws on Brampton

Another home-and-home winning weekend helped the Elmira Sugar Kings solidify their hold on top spot in the GOJHL’s Midwestern Conference. A pair of...

New St. Clements fire station officially open for service

The new fire station in St. Clements was officially declared open for service last Saturday. The $1.3-million project...
- Advertisement -