-4.3 C
Elmira
Friday, February 21, 2020
Connecting Our Communities

Wellesley councillors split over new fire truck purchase

TRENDING

News Briefs

Woolwich nixes traffic islands Displeased with the troublesome pedestrian islands installed during the Region of Waterloo’s reconstruction of Church Street...

20-year-old agreement causes a stir

An Elmira environmentalist’s “smoking gun” appears to be shooting blanks. Al Marshall, a long-time critic of cleanup efforts at...

Forks up to farmers on well-timed Agriculture Day

February is not the most obvious time to celebrate agriculture in Canada. But that’s...

EDSS student wins $5,000 scholarship to pursue his university education

Max Campbell’s dreams of perhaps one day making it to space got a down-to-Earth boost last week in the...

THIS WEEK

Elmira
clear sky
-4.3 ° C
-1.1 °
-6.1 °
62 %
2.1kmh
1 %
Fri
0 °
Sat
2 °
Sun
5 °
Mon
6 °
Tue
3 °

A new pumper truck is in the works for the Linwood fire station, but not without debate as Wellesley council was split on the merits of replacing the existing 15-year-old unit.

The price tag of up to $380,000 was cause for concern to Coun. Shelley Wagner, who unsuccessfully pushed Tuesday night to have the existing pumped inspected for possible further use.

The National Fire Protection Association recommends that fire departments replace their pumpers after 15 years, after which time the possibility of failure increases. Wagner, who interviewed the mechanics who inspect Wellesley’s trucks at Mike’s Auto Service, relayed that expenses on the pumper have been minimal, and that the current Linwood pumper is in good condition. She added that Wellesley’s fire trucks see less service than those of Waterloo and even Woolwich.

Township fire chief Andrew Lillico responded that the employees at Mike’s Auto Service are not emergency response specialists, and that a new pumper would be up to current standards. When asked about possible ramifications of ignoring the NFPA guidelines, Lillico said the township could be liable if the vehicle failed to start.

Kevin Beggs, general manager of community services, told council, “I don’t think any of our departments are blessed with extra equipment, so if a piece of equipment does go down, it’s down.”

Wagner suggested putting forward a motion to defer purchasing a new pumper until refurbishment of the old model had been considered.

“Part of doing good business is also checking your other options, and I don’t see why we don’t at least investigate having it refurbished to look at what our costs might be,” she said.

Coun. Herb Neher, however, leaned towards following the staff’s recommendation. “We have to be very careful. If we’re going to start to question every time we get a new truck and say, ‘This one might have seven years, this one might have six years,’ then we’re also have to ask ourselves: Do we want to take that additional risk?’”

He added, “Obviously these are guidelines; they are not mandatory … So we in council have to decide, ‘Do we get a cheaper deal the other way, but do we also want to take the risk factors associated with possible breakdowns?’”

Ultimately, Neher declined not to withdraw the motion to make room for a deferral by Wagner. “We have a program here in place. I rely on the integrity, on the professionalism, on the knowledge of the fire chief. I agree with the motion,” said Neher. The motion passed in a recorded vote 3-2, with Wagner and Mayor Ross Kelterborn voting against.

In an interview on Wednesday, Neher called the debate a symptom of “putting the cart before the horse” with regards to budget deliberations. He suggested that capital expenditures be proposed in advance of budget deliberations to offer more time for debate.

“We approved the budget – Shelley fully approved the budget, that was in the budget – but now that [Lillico] said, ‘Okay, I’m just going to present something that you’ve already approved,’ all of a sudden there’s this hoopla.”

Also cause for concern was the fact that Lillico would be visiting the manufacturer twice in New Brunswick to inspect the pumper and its design. Lillico noted that the first trip would be paid for entirely by a fire station tender sale fundraiser, and the manufacturer would cover accommodations on both trips. Chief administrative officer Willis McLaughlin pointed out that such trips are not uncommon, and said that after attending a similar inspection in Peterborough, “I had no doubt it was in the interest of the taxpayers to have it done.”

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to The Observer's online community. Pseudonyms are not permitted. By submitting a comment, you accept that The Observer has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner The Observer chooses. Please note that The Observer does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our submission guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

LIVING HERE

Under the auctioneer’s gavel to provide help Down Under

After seeing the devastation from the Australian wildfires, a local art collector sold the first painting she ever bought on Saturday to help raise money for relief efforts there. Nancy...

In Print. Online. In Pictures. In Depth.

You obviously love community journalism. Thanks for visiting today. If you have a great local story, let us know.

EDSS performers take Broadway under the sea

By Steve Kannon skannon@woolwichobserver.com The tropics, under the sea or otherwise, seem like a much better place...

Sugar Kings win three games, clinch first place

In need of just one more win to clinch first place in the Midwestern Conference, the Elmira Sugar Kings claimed all three games...

U.S. edges out Canada in national para hockey battle

In the natural on-ice rivalry between Canada and the U.S., the American para hockey team has had the advantage in recent years. That...
- Advertisement -